Not all neighbors are as friendly as Mr. Rogers. While some invite you in for a cup of tea, others limit you to the porch. A few merely gawk from behind shuttered windows.
The same responses happen when you market to consumers. Seth Godin is a genius for reminding marketers to mind their manners, and ask permission rather than barging in.
But you can’t afford “yes” or “no” answers when asking permission.
You’ll either forgo deep relationships by staying on the porch, or have only a few relationships with those willing to share a cup of tea. Instead, find a way to build the deepest-possible, permission-based relationship with both the gawkers and Mr. Rogers.
Offer more than two answers when you ask permission. Add another channel.
Allow Mr. Rogers to invite you into the house. Allow the gawkers to feel comfortable lurking. Provide a highly personalized e-mail list, and an informative (and anonymous) website.
Vary the frequency.
Provide a daily RSS feed and an annual e-mail list.
Create a daily Twitter feed for your group.
Unfortunately, most consumers don’t even know what they want. Offer them three choices, and most will pick the middle. (Tip: Define the middle.) Restaurant menus are great examples of this. Most menus have four (or more) price-levels.
The final twist: Consumers love to feel powerful, but hate making decisions. So provide choices, but not too many. Don’t annoy people by asking whether they’ll allow you two steps inside their house or three. Besides, the less you push their boundaries, the less threatened they feel–they shouldn’t be second-guessing their choice.
Build a decision process that customers enjoy. A good restaurant menu makes ordering fun!